From 24 September, the massive US legal dispute pitting OpenAI and Microsoft against authors and publishers will enter a decisive phase. The parties will seek to have the opposing expert reports dismissed, in particular those intended to assess the competition posed by AI-generated content to the works used to train the AI. Yet this issue lies at the heart of the fair use defence invoked by OpenAI, and on which the judge in the Kadrey v Meta case had left the door wide open for rights holders.